The
Dip Me in Molasses and Call Me Shirley may have one of the oldest and richest histories of
any poetic form. The form dates back to Ancient Sumeria, where archaeologists
have found five-line stanzas using words from the preceding stanza inscribed on
the walls of ziggurats. The traditional name for this kind of stanza was either
“coat the high priest with pitch tar and call him Surshlash,” or “the one with
the honorary title ‘Shurlash’ is covered in resin,” translators remain divided.
This likely refers to the embalming practices for the bodies of high priests.
The form appears to have been preserved through the Mesopotamians and
Babylonians, as several key passages from the Epic of Gilgamesh are written in
a similar form, most notably the scene in which Enkidu burns down the cedars in
Lebanon after being mocked by the goddess Mishmash for putting his left boot on
his right foot. The form was also one of the most popular in use by the common
people of Babylon…
The
tradition was adopted by the Jews during the Babylonian captivity, and was
brought back to Jerusalem, where it was used as the format for a number of
psalms and various other passages of the old testament, notably the book of
Amos. Following the conquest of Alexander the Great and the establishment of
the Selucid Empire, the form was adopted to Greek, which flourished in not only
the Selucid Empire itself, but within Ptolemaic Egypt and the Greek Mainland
itself. At this point there is no evidence that the sixth stanza had developed.
The Greeks only used the pattern seen in the first five stanzas. Most were
written in dactylic hexameter.
Virgil,
Pliny the Elder, and Cicero all wrote this form, but it was not popular with
the Roman nobility. In fact, the Emperor Nero threatened Pliny the Elder with
being impaled from the anus to the mouth if he “wrote one more stanza of [that]
detestable form!” The form would disappear from the European continent for over
a millennium.
The tradition,
however, had survived through Greco-Bactrian traders on the Silk Road, who
would compose long songs in this form to pass the time as their caravans rode
through the Taklimakan Desert. Few were written down, but from what has been
recorded, it seems that this was where the form of the sixth stanza developed,
sung as a kind of refrain. However, this stanza would never change throughout
the entire song, which would sometimes last for upwards of one hundred stanza.
The skill of the poet would be measured by how many stanzas he could
manufacture using the same end-words in the same configuration, but with
different content and meaning.
Emperor Han
Shundi received one such merchant and was so impressed by his abilities to
improvise that he commissioned all one hundred and sixty seven of his court
poets to write similar poems, and executed the poets whose work he deemed
unworthy. His method of execution was to dip them in a thick boiling liquid
known as “fang gao,” which was described as resembling tar but smelling of
young lychee blossoms. The form was therefore known as “feng gao dip shrieking
tradition.”
Famous navigator
Zeng He brought copies of his favorite poems with him on his voyages, and one of
them was a poem composed in the early-modern Dip Me in Molasses form, which he
read to the Sultan of Zanzibar as an overture of diplomatic goodwill. Despite
some adaptation in mainland Tanzania by tribal populations under the cruel heel of the Sultan, the form would see little use until its
reading was again used as a token of diplomatic goodwill, this time to
Portuguese explorer Vazco Da Gama, who brought it back to Portugal where it
gained wide use among the Portuguese nobility.
In his later
years, Milton penned what were allegedly translations of a “mergulhe me no molaço,”
but were actually creations of his own. His senile brain is thought to have
imagined poems allegedly in some language vaguely Portuguese-sounding. The “translations”
themselves are mostly gibberish. Never the less, Byron, Wordswroth, Keats, and
Coleridge all tried their hand at the form, finding it to be, in Byron’s words,
“so bombastedly complicated and inelegante that it is only suitable for orphanes,
trampes, and streete urchines of the loweste birthe.”
Meanwhile the
Portuguese tradition continued, coming with the Empire to Brazil, where it
flourished among Amazonian and Highland backwaters, before spreading to the
Pampas and eventually to Buenos Aires, where it was discovered by Borges. It
was in this form that he wrote his long narrative “Un Sueño de mi Sudamerica Cósmico,”
(A Dream of My Cosmic South America), which was mostly a thinly veiled critique
of the Pinochet regime in neighboring Chile.
The form got its
English name from Brazilian immigrant João Fermin da Cunha arriving at Ellis
Island in 1893. When trying to explain the pronunciation of his name to immigration
officials, one official was reported to have said “Well dip me in molasses and
call me Shirley, where did you get a name like that?” Da Cunha promptly changed
his name to John Clemens to avoid any future confusion. But the phrase had
stuck in his mind, and he penned a poem in the form which now bears this phrase
as its name. It became wildly popular, posted on broadsides across the nation.
It did not, however, catch on with educated city dwellers. Carrie Nation wrote
an anti-liquor propaganda poem called “The Dip Me in Molasses and Call Me
Shirley of Prohibition,” and the Woodrow Wilson campaign was known to have
distributed pamphlets with Dip Me in Molasses poems to remind voters to get to
the polls while keeping their black neighbors from doing so.
It was for this
reason that Langston Hughes and Countee Cullen appropriated the form, feeling
that it would empower blacks who were disenfranchised at the polls. The Duke
Ellington Orchestra performed “The Dip Me in Molasses (And Call Me Shirley)
Suite” to commemorate Hughes’ and Cullen’s work.
Ginsberg, in his
early years, dabbled with the form in his early years, but found it to be “too
heavy, maaan.” However, an early draft of “Howl” was found among Ginsberg’s
papers after his death, indicating that he had intended to write his magnum opus
as a Dip Me in Molasses before abandoning the idea.
The form has
seen recent resurgence thanks to its frequent use by poet Billy Collins, and
many alt-lit “authors” (the term used very liberally) on the blogosphere. A
recent adaptation has been the “Tweet Me in Molasses,” where Twitter users
collaborate to create an entire poem, tweeting one line at a time. There is
also resurgent interest in places where the form has history, including Iraq,
Xinxiang, Tanzania, Portugal, Brazil, Argentina, and New York City. President
Obama has stated that after his second inaugural address, current poet laureate
Natasha Tretheway will read a Dip Me in Molasses and Call Me Shirley. He hopes
this poem will be less of a disaster than the last one.



